Only two criminal convictions permanently bar you from Section 8: lifetime sex offender registration and manufacturing methamphetamine in federally assisted housing. Everything else, including drug convictions, violent felonies, and misdemeanors, is at your PHA's discretion. Many PHAs have relaxed their screening criteria in recent years, and HUD guidance encourages case-by-case review rather than blanket bans.
The two lifetime bans
Federal rules (24 CFR 982.553(a)) require PHAs to deny assistance for life in exactly two situations:
1. Lifetime registered sex offenders. If any household member is subject to a lifetime sex offender registration requirement, the household is permanently ineligible.
2. Meth manufacturing in assisted housing. If any household member has been convicted of manufacturing methamphetamine on the premises of federally assisted housing, the household is permanently ineligible.
A few other rules are required but not permanent. If someone in your household was evicted from federally assisted housing for drug-related criminal activity, the PHA has to deny admission for 3 years. It can still let you in if that person finished an approved rehab program or the circumstances no longer exist. PHAs must also have rules to deny anyone currently using illegal drugs, or whose drug use or alcohol abuse may threaten other residents. The rest of your criminal history is up to the PHA.
What your PHA gets to decide
Outside those federal rules, each PHA has wide latitude to write its own criminal history policy. The most common screens:
Drug-related criminal activity. A PHA may deny you if anyone in the household engaged in drug-related criminal activity within a "reasonable time." Many PHAs read that as 3-5 years.
Violent criminal activity. A PHA may deny you if it decides a household member's criminal activity could threaten other residents' health, safety, or right to peaceful enjoyment.
Two screens aren't up to the PHA, though. Federal rules require them. A PHA must deny for 3 years after a household member was evicted from federally assisted housing for drug-related criminal activity, unless that person has completed a PHA-approved drug rehabilitation program or the circumstances behind the eviction no longer exist (24 CFR 982.553). And a PHA must deny if it determines anyone in the household currently uses illegal drugs.
HUD wants case-by-case decisions
In recent years HUD has pushed PHAs toward individualized assessments. Its guidance says a PHA should weigh how serious the offense was, how much time has passed, evidence of rehabilitation, and the effect on other residents.
HUD strongly discourages blanket bans based on arrest records without convictions. A PHA should treat an arrest and a conviction differently, and an arrest alone shouldn't be the reason you're denied. Many PHAs have updated their policies to match, with shorter lookback periods and a focus on convictions instead of arrests.
How to Strengthen Your Application
Get your records first. Request your criminal history from your state's repository so you know exactly what the PHA will see.
Gather proof of what you've done since. That means completion certificates from drug treatment, anger management, or other programs, your work history, letters from employers, counselors, probation officers, or community members, and a record of stable housing since the conviction.
Write a personal statement. Some PHAs will take one. Explain what happened, what you've done since, and why you're a good candidate for housing assistance.
Read the PHA's own policy. Every PHA publishes an Administrative Plan, and its criminal history screening criteria are in there. Some PHAs have shorter lookback periods or looser standards than others, so read that section before you apply.
Apply to more than one PHA. Policies differ a lot. The PHA that turns you down may simply be stricter than the one in the next county.
If You're Denied
If a PHA denies you over criminal history, you have the right to an informal hearing to contest it. Bring your evidence of rehabilitation. You can challenge anything on the record that's wrong, and you can argue that the denial doesn't match the PHA's own published criteria.
Legal aid offices handle these cases all the time, and having one in your corner can significantly improve your chances at a hearing.
Expungement and Record Sealing
If your state lets you expunge or seal a record, look into it. Expunged records generally don't show up on background checks. Many states have widened who qualifies in recent years. Your local legal aid office can tell you whether you do.